1051109498268490
top of page

Was Jesus Necessary?

Was it necessary for God to do what He did—to come in bodily form, endure overwhelming abuse, and suffer and die for the very people who would ultimately put Him to death?


Perhaps I enjoy controversy too much, but I believe controversy that drives deep thought is a must when it comes to believers growing in their faith and knowledge of God’s Word. I also believe this is the crux of what it means for “iron to sharpen iron.”So, to answer our leading question, “Was it necessary for God to do what He did—to come in bodily form, endure overwhelming abuse, and suffer and die for the very people who would ultimately put Him to death?” the short answer is no.


This blog post will be followed by an upcoming podcast titled “Do You Need Jesus?” The answer to that question is also no.


If you are surprised by those answers, read on to discover why.


Our first question asks whether God had to send Jesus as the atoning sacrifice for our sins. The answer is no, because God can do things however He chooses. God is not locked into or confined by anything within the cosmos. All options are at His disposal. Furthermore, our understanding of what is possible is limited by our finite minds. After all, God knows and understands things we could never conceive.


Based on this, God had an infinite number of options for extending His offer of salvation without appearing in bodily form as a human being, Jesus. Salvation did not have to involve God taking on human flesh, and sin itself never had to be permitted in the first place.


Obviously, God did not choose to do things the way we might have perceived as the most logical or perhaps the most thoughtful approach. Yet God acted with exceptional logic and thoughtfulness, doing things in a way that allows us to understand and make sense of why He chose the path He did.


God is very much a God of order and reason. While there is room to discuss this at great length, the short version, for the sake of this discussion, is this: God is all about relationships.


From the very beginning, we see God creating living beings, from angels, cherubim, and seraphim to His greatest earthly creation of all—us, human beings. He created living beings to share in His goodness and experience the love He desires to give freely. To that end, He gave angels and humans free will: the ability to make personal choices. That is truly thoughtful, kind, and loving. It is also logical, as we understand logic.


Without free will, we would be nothing more than puppets. And there can be no genuine relationship with a puppet. Therefore, God gave us the freedom to choose whether or not we would follow Him.


He allowed the angels to make their own choices, and, as we know all too well, some chose to rebel and go their own way. God allowed the consequences of those choices to unfold. But was that fair to us? Was it fair that, because some angels chose to rebel, their actions would affect the world God had created for all humanity? At first glance, we might question why God would allow such a thing to happen.


But keep in mind that, just like the angels, we, too, have free will and are responsible for the direction we choose. God went one step further, however. Knowing in advance what we would choose, He put a perfect way out into place. That is love!


God knew in advance that we would reject Him—not just once in the Garden of Eden, but repeatedly, from that moment to this very second. Yet He has continued, without fail, to offer us the opportunity to turn from our mistakes and return to Him.


You see, we are not trapped in a predetermined doom. Just as we have the freedom to do wrong, we have the freedom to do right. Our God given free will gives us the option to choose either direction. God also did not shortchange us by making the right choice impossible.


God also knew we would struggle with this. So, not only did He provide a way for us to be forgiven and reconciled to Him, He went one step further: He showed Himself to us as one of us.


God knew that our minds often crave visual evidence to help us make decisions about what we will or will not believe and do. In this respect alone, we should be eternally grateful that God has given us such extraordinary freedom. I do not know anyone who enjoys being denied the freedom to make personal choices. After all, isn't that what so much of the world is about—freedom to choose?


How, then, could anyone be upset with God for giving us the very thing we seem to crave most?


The problem is that we often want freedom with guardrails of our own making. We want what we want and how we chose it to be, but when our choices get us into trouble, we want to blame something beyond ourselves. Very often that something we like to blame is God for giving us the freedom to make those choices in the first place.


We say, “If God were such a loving and caring God, He would never have allowed this mess to happen, and be in the predicament I’m in!”


Perhaps that sounds familiar. If you have ever thought this way, as many people have, consider what you are actually saying. You are suggesting that you wish God had not given the freedom to make your own decisions. In effect, you are asking God to control your choices like a marionette.

Yet if God had done precisely that, would we not accuse Him of being controlling, untrusting, and lacking compassion because He refused to give us the freedom to make our own decisions?


We cannot reasonably demand the freedom to choose and then blame God whenever our choices lead to consequences we do not like.


So, was it necessary for God to do what He did—to come in bodily form, endure overwhelming abuse, and suffer and die for the very people who would ultimately put Him to death?


The answer is still no. God was not limited to this one possible course of action. Yet He chose to do things in a way that speaks directly to our understanding, our needs, and our desire for a relationship with Him.

We want the freedom to make our own choices—we have it. We want a way back when we make mistakes—He has provided it. We want evidence to help us make informed decisions—He has revealed Himself to us. And we want the ability to choose our own direction—He has given us that freedom, too.


God has provided us with the freedom to choose, the opportunity for reconciliation, and the revelation of Himself through Jesus Christ.


Ask yourself: What more could you reasonably want that God has not already freely offered you, leaving you free to decide how you will respond?

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Four Peaks Christian Church Arizona
©2024-2026 Four Peaks Christian Church
A 501(c)3 Non-profit organization
bottom of page