Judging Others
The subject of having a judgmental attitude comes up fairly often in conversation. However, it usually matters most when we are the ones being judged. We talk about how awful it feels when someone judges us, but we don't often spend much time considering how judgmental we can be toward others.
And in this post, we'll focus on one particular type of judgment that is all too common within the church, and explore just how damaging and ungodly it is.
The truth is, many church congregants often serve as both judge and jury, forming opinions about people we barely know and drawing conclusions without knowing the whole story. So, what does that look like, and more importantly, what does God's Word have to say about it?
James 2:1 reminds us that believers in Jesus Christ must not show favoritism. James goes on to describe the sin of treating a wealthy person with honor while humiliating someone who is poor. He concludes with these words: “Mercy triumphs over judgment” (James 2:13).
But does this mean we should never judge or evaluate anyone's actions? Not at all. To understand what God expects of us, we must look at the whole counsel of Scripture.
Consider the familiar words of Jesus in Matthew 7:1–5:
“Judge not, that you be not judged.”
Jesus then describes someone attempting to remove a speck from another person's eye while overlooking a log in their own. His instruction is clear: “First take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother's eye.”
Notice what Jesus says. He doesn't tell us to ignore the speck in someone else's eye. He tells us to address our own shortcomings first so that we can see clearly enough to help someone else.
The problem isn't simply recognizing wrongdoing. The problem is condemning others while knowing nothing about them and refusing to confront our own sins. It is hypocrisy—holding others to a standard we are unwilling to apply to ourselves.
Paul reinforces this principle in Romans 2:3, warning that when we condemn others for practicing the very things we do ourselves, we condemn (judge) ourselves.
So, yes, we must examine our own lives before attempting to correct someone else's.
But Scripture also commands discernment. In 1 John 4:1, we are told to test the spirits to determine whether they are from God. Jesus likewise warns us about false prophets and tells us, “You will recognize them by their fruits” (Matthew 7:16).
We cannot blindly accept everything people teach or do. We must evaluate what we see and hear according to God's Word. The distinction is that we must not confuse biblical truth with personal preferences, outward appearances, or unsupported assumptions.
So how do we approach someone when we believe their actions are contrary to Scripture?
First, examine your motives. Are you confronting them because you dislike their behavior, want to prove a point, or believe yourself superior? Or do you genuinely care about them and want to help them grow in their relationship with God?
Godly correction begins with humility. It means listening, asking thoughtful questions, and pointing someone toward God's Word rather than simply imposing our opinions. Our goal should never be to shame or condemn, but to encourage someone to recognize the truth and draw closer to Christ.
Think again about that log in your eye. Imagine walking through a room with a 46-foot telephone pole sticking straight out in front of your face. Every time you turned your head, you would risk damaging everything and everyone around you.
That is a powerful picture of the destruction we can cause when we judge others without examining ourselves.
Every one of us has been guilty of this at some point. I know I have. That is why we must continually allow God's Word to correct us and shape our attitudes.
The next time you feel compelled to judge someone, stop and ask yourself: Am I responding according to God's Word, or according to my own assumptions? Have I examined my own life? And am I approaching this person out of genuine love and concern?
God calls us to discern truth, confront our own shortcomings, and help others with humility and mercy. May we never confuse self-righteous condemnation with godly correction, but instead reflect the grace and truth of Jesus Christ in the way we treat others.





Comments